Trading More, Earning Less: The Data That Should Change Your Strategy

FinStrike helps teens build real-world money skills through a four-year financial literacy curriculum, a Smart Tutor that helps students around the clock, and extensive free resources for parents and students.

Let’s cut to it. The more investors trade, the worse they tend to do. Not my opinion. It's just how investing plays out. A Journal of Finance study looked at 66,465 brokerage accounts. The most active traders earned about 11.4 percent a year while the market returned roughly 17.9 percent. That gap is not a rounding error. It's important to acknowledge when developing a trading strategy.

Why Activity Feels Smart, Then Fails

Active feels good. You tap a button. You feel in control, and you feel informed. Zero-commission apps make it effortless. Headlines scream opportunity, friends brag, fear kicks in, and suddenly you are tinkering with a portfolio that would have been fine if you had just left it alone.

The problem is simple. Every trade has a cost. Spreads, taxes, bad timing, and emotions that make you buy high and sell low. The busier you are, the worse off you'll be.

The Boring Strategy That Wins

Here is the play that beats most people who cannot sit still. Diversify broadly, automate contributions, keep costs low, and let time work. Own the market instead of trying to outsmart it. Rebalance on a schedule, not on a headline. Avoid concentrated bets unless you can afford for them to go to zero. Keep cash for short-term needs so you are not forced to sell when markets dip.

If you want excitement, play video games. If you want results, build a system that runs whether you are paying attention or not.

How to Put This on Autopilot

1. Pick a simple allocation. For most people, a total U.S. stock index, a total international stock index, and a high-quality bond fund.

2. Automate it. Set monthly transfers from checking to your investment account. Treat it like a bill.

3. Rebalance once or twice a year. Move back to your targets, do not chase winners.

4. Minimize taxes. Use Roth accounts for long-term growth if you qualify, harvest losses in taxable accounts when it makes sense, and avoid needless short-term gains.

5. Write a one-page plan. What you own, why you own it, when you will rebalance. Read it before you are tempted to trade.

Here is the mindset shift. Investing is not a talent show. It is a patience contest. The market rewards time in the market, not time spent fiddling with trades. That is true for you, and it is the single best lesson you can pass to your teen. Show them how to build a simple plan, automate it, and ignore the noise. Patience beats tinkering. Every time.